What do you remember about what you were taught at school? Shakespeare? Algebra? How to ask for directions to the train station in French? I bet one thing you were not taught is what makes a really healthy strong relationship. I understand the school curriculum is, or at least was, designed to prepare us for entering the work place but who was preparing us for entering into and thriving in our intimate relationships? Chances are no one, which is curious when you think about the impact strong healthy partnerships have in our life-from improved physical and emotional health to increased longevity.
It’s a sad reality that 42% of marriages end in divorce in the UK and this doesn’t account for the number of people living in unhappy relationships. And when our relationship is suffering, so are we. The topic of dissatisfaction and conflict in our most intimate relationship is not just grist for the mill in couples therapy but is also a frequent topic of conversation in individual therapy. There has been an explosion of research into the psychology of unhappy marriages and divorce and thankfully, with the help of therapists and researchers like the Gottman’s we now have a robust understanding of what can lead couples to separate and divorce. But what about our understanding around what makes a satisfying and fulfilling relationship? Thankfully this is getting more attention and I wanted to share some key findings from this area of research according to Dr Pat Love who is an acclaimed therapist, speaker and author and a clinical practitioner of marriage and family therapy for over 40 years.
First and foremost is a sense of security which can be broken down into physical, emotional, financial and attachment security. Physical security is unlikely to come as much of a surprise as most of us appreciate that healthy relationships are free from physical abuse and violence. However non-violent communication, for example non ridiculing, non rejecting and non defensive communication is also essential for healthy relationships. This, alongside the capacity to stay emotionally regulated much of the time (of course we are human and all have our moments-but this should never escalate to violence) is what we mean when we talk about emotional security. Marsha felt very secure physically and emotionally with her long term boyfriend Marvin but when it came to money and spending behaviour they were like chalk and cheese. Marsha valued saving money but felt Marvin was reckless, something that was confirmed when he immediately bought a very expensive Porsche after a small pay rise at work, despite them having some credit card debt and saving for a deposit for a house. Not being reckless with joint finances and being committed to the financial health of the relationship is imperative for financial security. This doesn’t mean a couple should contribute 50/50 to all expenses but if they contribute proportionate amounts to what each person earns this shows a commitment to share in the financial security of the relationship. The final, and perhaps least understood type of security is attachment security. Attachment security is essential for children to feel in their relationship with their caregivers but this same need also shows up in our adult intimate relationship. Strong attachment security is fostered when couples spend enough time connecting with each other, prioritise their relationship (over work or friends or family) , are present and available (not always distracted or busy), attuned, thoughtful (I am writing this on a plane and whenever I fly with my husband he always gives me the window seat as he knows how mesmerized I get with the views from an aircraft), trustworthy, emotionally regulated, consistent and dependable. Moreover if a couple’s behaviour is congruent on their understanding of each other, this strongly increases attachment security as it helps us feel seen. I remember one of my clients telling me a story of how her husband bought her very expensive branded high heel shoes every birthday, which in his mind he thought she would be very grateful for and yet the problem was that my client hated wearing high heeled shoes and would have much preferred some comfy slippers! Perhaps her husband struggled to let go of his idea of what makes for a good present and deeply attune to her preferences and wants which would have helped her feel more seen by him.
The second factor necessary for a healthy relationship is a sense of equitability and fairness. Similar to financial security this doesn’t mean that all bills or tasks a couple shares should be 50/50 but rather a couple should feel that in the big scheme of things things feel fair. This requires the emotional work of raising a family and looking after a home having as much value as making money which sadly is still often not the case. I would also caution couples against score keeping as this is a significant red flag to happy relationships.
Score keeping often involves an ‘I’ mentality. What do I mean by this? I mean a focus on “I do this and I do that and you do nothing”. This mentality of ‘I’ versus ‘you’ shows up in all sorts of facets in relationships-not least in arguments (eg I am right, you are wrong). However if you want to strengthen your relationship I strongly encourage you to adopt a sense of ‘we’ over ‘I’. This type of relational thinking is the third key factor in building strong healthy relationships. With relational thinking each partner is aware of how their decisions and actions affect their partner and their relationship, not just them. My client Elsa was very focused on proving her point in an argument and whilst this felt important for her as she was never allowed to assert herself growing up it was not good for her relationship. Learning to let go of her need to prove a point (this doesn’t mean subjugating or acquiescing) and instead focusing on moving back into connection with her boyfriend greatly benefited her relationship. Relational thinking also requires us to reflect on what it is like for our partner to be in a relationship with us, not just how it is for us to be in relationship with them!
So far we have covered security, fairness and relational thinking as the key components of a secure healthy relationship. Now I want to cover flexibility which is a real gift to relationships. If you can be flexible about the roles you play in the relationship, the responsibilities you take on and your expectations (e.g. you can downsize if you have to due to a changed financial situation) this can help avoid a lot of resentment and arguments. Whilst we often fall into roles in a relationship, the unpredictability of life means we may have to shake this up so when Derick, who hated cooking, was flexible and thus prepared to take on the chore of cooking the evening meal when his boyfriend James broke his wrist this helped James feel cherished and greatly benefited their relationship.
Feeling cared about and loved is so essential to a secure functioning relationship that its importance can’t be overstated. However so is a sense of aliveness which is the fifth factor of a healthy relationship. A strong relationship has interest and passion and I don’t just mean sexual passion. Do you and your partner expand each other’s lives? Do you share ideas with each other and bring expansion to your partner and the relationship? Novelty and spontaneity can help with aliveness for example visiting new places together or trying out a new hobby or activity together.
It is unrealistic to expect that all the five elements listed above will be consistently prioritized over the course of a lifelong relationship but they certainly give us a guide post and something to aim for if we want to have a strong healthy relationship. If you are interested in exploring your relationship dynamics further with the support of a therapist then we offer a safe space to do this in both individual and couples therapy.